The Price of Malice Read online

  THE

  PRICE OF MALICE

  OTHER BOOKS BY ARCHER MAYOR

  The Catch

  Chat

  The Second Mouse

  St. Albans Fire

  The Surrogate Thief

  Gatekeeper

  The Sniper’s Wife

  Tucker Peak

  The Marble Mask

  Occam’s Razor

  The Disposable Man

  Bellows Falls

  The Ragman’s Memory

  The Dark Root

  Fruits of the Poisonous Tree

  The Skeleton’s Knee

  Scent of Evil

  Borderlines

  Open Season

  THE

  PRICE OF MALICE

  A Joe Gunther Novel

  ARCHER MAYOR

  Minotaur Books

  New York

  This is a work of fiction. All of the characters, organizations, and events portrayed in this novel are either products of the author’s imagination or are used fictitiously.

  THE PRICE OF MALICE. Copyright © 2009 by Archer Mayor. All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America. For information address St. Martin’s Press, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010.

  www.minotaurbooks.com

  LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOGING-IN-PUBLICATION DATA

  Mayor, Archer.

  The price of malice : a Joe Gunther novel / Archer Mayor. — 1st ed.

  p. cm.

  ISBN 978-0-312-38192-9

  1. Gunther, Joe (Fictitious character)—Fiction. 2. Murder—Investigation—Fiction. 3. New England—Fiction. I. Title.

  PS3563.A965P75 2009

  813'.54—dc22

  2009016657

  First Edition: October 2009

  10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1

  To Paco, my longtime friend and sounding board

  ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

  As always, I owe a great deal of thanks to many people for the creation of this book. I start each new foray into Joe Gunther’s continuing adventures pretty much as a blank slate, dependent on those who know far more than I for the interesting details for which this series has become known. It is those experts and advisors who deserve whatever praise you might have for any interesting and arcane tidbits you’ll encounter. It is left to me to accept the blame for any inevitable mistakes and omissions left over.

  My gratitude, therefore, to my readers and to the following:

  John Martin

  Nancy Polseno

  Anne Emerson

  Dan Davis

  Rick Bates

  Sally Mattson

  Dick and Jean Hoyt

  Lauren Petrie

  Paco Aumand

  Will Hoyt

  Eric Buel

  Elaine Sopchak

  Nancy Aichele

  Ray Walker

  Castle Freeman, Jr.

  Julie Lavorgna

  Peter van Wageningen

  Lisa Keller

  Also:

  The Brattleboro Police Department

  The Vermont State Police

  Immigration and Customs Enforcement

  The Vermont Forensic Lab

  The Department of Children and Families

  THE

  PRICE OF MALICE

  CHAPTER ONE

  Willy Kunkle gently removed his one functional hand from the bare back of the woman stretched out beside him and reached for the softly buzzing cell phone on the night table. Unlike Sammie Martens—the woman in question—Willy had been termed a “vigilant sleeper,” which sounded like psychobabble to him. He didn’t need a shrink to tell him that he slept like shit.

  “What?” he asked in a muted growl, noticing the first pale hint of dawn against the window shade.

  “That you, Willy?”

  It was Ron Klesczewski, chief of detectives of Brattleboro, Vermont, an old colleague of Willy’s before he and Sam had left the PD to join the Vermont Bureau of Investigation, a new, statewide major crimes unit. As far as Willy was concerned, Ron was a perfect example of the Peter Principle. Way too touchy-feely for Willy’s taste, he’d never have landed the top job if the rest of them hadn’t jumped ship.

  “Jesus, Ron. Who do you think it is? You called me.”

  Ron laughed, unfazed. “I’m just used to you yelling into the phone. You sound downright demure.”

  Willy rolled his eyes, as much at the word choice as at Sam’s stirring from all the noise.

  “What the hell do you want?”

  “You’re the VBI on call, according to your dispatch,” Ron explained brightly, “and I got something for you.”

  “You lock your keys in the car again?”

  Klesczewski ignored him, slowly enunciating, “Ho-mi-cide.”

  Willy smiled abruptly, his mood improved as if by the flick of a switch. “Say that again for what’s-her-name.”

  Ron repeated himself as Willy dangled the phone just above Sammie’s exposed ear. He was rewarded as her eyes opened wide and she sat up in one fluid motion.

  “Who is that?” she mouthed silently.

  “Your buddy Ron,” Willy said, bringing the phone back to his mouth. “Throwing us a local, at last. What is it, in under a thousand words?” Willy asked Klesczewski.

  “Single white male, done in with a knife; unknown assailant,” Ron responded, his smile almost audible. He then gave the exact address on Manor Court, off of Canal, between Clark Street and Homestead—a hard-luck neighborhood a stone’s throw from downtown. He hung up without further ceremony, having given Willy only precisely what he’d requested.

  Willy laughed and closed the phone. “That boy’s growing balls.”

  Sam was already across the room, getting dressed. “A minor miracle, given how much you bust ’em.”

  The name Manor Court sounded like a mass-produced, 1970s, northeastern development, in the way that Flamingo Estates brought to mind a Florida flophouse of fifty squirrel-sized apartments. In fact, it was neither a development nor a court, and hadn’t been touched by a builder’s level in 150 years. It was a residual holdover of Brattleboro’s nineteenth-century industrial past, when the town cranked out everything from parlor organs to baby carriages and had neighborhoods so clearly class-divided, it felt like some residents required passports for travel.

  Manor Court had once been an open-ended street, which—as with some rivers—implied a sense of cleansing circulation. But subsequent traffic engineering had turned it into a J-shaped dead end, a tidal pool of sorts, located in a section of town relatively downtrodden to this day. The dominant architecture was both the famed working-class “triple decker” so much in evidence in a hundred other soot-stained, reinvented, ancient New England towns, and a less definable, two-and-a-half-story structure—often clad in scalloped, gray, pressed-board siding—whose sole distinguishable attribute was that it didn’t look like anything more than a roof over four walls of marginal integrity.

  The address Ron Klesczewski had offered was one of the former—and therefore of modest historical merit—minus any grace notes of subsequent care or maintenance. In fact, as Willy swung out of the car he and Sammie shared to get there, he wondered if the electrical and phone lines looping in from the nearby utility pole weren’t the only modern amenities added over the prior seventy-five years.

  Including the paint on the walls.

  “You ever been here?” he asked his partner.

  Sam was reaching into the back seat to grab a canvas shoulder bag she favored for crime-scene investigations. “Seems like our kind of place, but I don’t know for sure.”

  Willy was standing by the car, studying the structure in the slowly growing dawn. It was peeling, sagging, and gaping where stair and balcony railings had vanished over time. His left hand, as
always, was stuffed into his pants pocket—the useless tail end of an arm crippled years ago by a rifle round received in the line of duty. His powerful right hand remained empty. No extra equipment for him, not at this early stage.

  “A hanging—about eight years ago.”

  Sammie pulled her head out of the car. “What?”

  “A hanging,” he repeated. “That’s it. About eight years ago. That’s how I know this dump.”

  She smiled, if just barely. Trust him to remember that—and almost everything else, in fact, except the everyday rules of social conduct. In that way, he reminded her of an idiot savant who could play the concert piano but not read a comic book. The man was a dinosaur—an old-fashioned, old-school cop—a black-and-white man in a colorful world. She loved him for that, among other quirks.

  She adjusted her bag and motioned across the street. “Shall we?”

  There were already two PD cruisers parked by the curb, along with an unmarked Impala that should have had “cop” stamped on both doors. A couple of patrolmen were stringing crime-scene tape around the building, and a third was loitering by the entrance at the top of the rickety porch steps, clipboard in hand.

  A broad smile creased his weather-beaten face as he caught sight of them approaching.

  “Oh, oh—watch out. It’s the cavalry.”

  The two of them spoke simultaneously, Sam saying, “Hey, Zippo. How you been?” while Willy responded, “It’s the brain trust, asshole, come to save your butt again.”

  Zippo just laughed, knowing them both well. “Beauty and the Beast. God help us.” He jerked his thumb over his shoulder and applied pen to clipboard as he spoke. “Second floor, apartment three.”

  They filed by, into the fetid embrace of the dark first-floor lobby, stifling even at this early hour. Summer had kicked in at last, following a winter of more snowfall than the region had seen in years. Typically, it had taken barely a week for everyone to switch from enjoying the warmth to complaining about the heat. New Englanders tend to be hardier in the cold than they are in its absence, making Florida as the terminus for so many of them conceptually rational only because of its universal air-conditioning.

  “Jesus,” Willy groaned. As Sam well knew, the man—despite his marginal manners—was a neat freak at heart, and while he spent most of his time working in these environments, his soul quailed at the squalor.

  At the second-floor landing, they were met by a poster boy for the average American male Caucasian.

  Sammie walked up to him and gave him a hug. “Ron, it’s great to see you. How’s the family?”

  Ron nodded to Willy over her shoulder. “Hi, guys. Everybody’s great. How’re you doin’, Willy?”

  Willy frowned and glanced at the open door of the nearby apartment. “I’m doin’. This the place?”

  Ron broke from Sam and bowed slightly at the waist in mock homage. “It is. We’ve staged down the hall, there. You can get a Tyvek suit and booties and the rest from Phil. I also called the crime lab. Their ETA is maybe another two hours.”

  Willy’s frown deepened. “I’ll believe that when I see it. You’re making this sound like a whodunit.”

  Ron nodded. “So far, it is. The dead guy is Wayne Castine, thirty-two. He was stabbed a bunch of times, and maybe shot and beaten, too. It’s hard to tell with the blood. It’s all over him, and all over the apartment.”

  “He live here alone?” Sam asked as Willy headed for where Phil was waiting with the crime-scene equipment.

  “He didn’t live here at all, and the woman who does swears she doesn’t know who he is.” Ron paused before rephrasing. “Correction—she says she doesn’t know Wayne Castine. Making a visual ID on this guy is a little tough right now. She might know him but not his name.”

  “Do we know her?” Sam asked, in the age-old shorthand for, is she in the computer for any past misbehavior?

  “Some speeding tickets,” he answered. “Two DUIs over the past two years; a couple of domestics as the victim; a few public disturbances involving alcohol. She’s been a person-of-interest in a dozen or more cases, hanging with a tough crowd.” He held his hands out to both sides, palms up, in a hapless gesture. “Name’s Elisabeth Babbitt—British-style spelling. Calls herself Liz. She’s pretty down and out, like everybody else on the block. Only moved here a couple of months ago. Lived in West Bratt before that; Bellows Falls before that; north of Putney in a trailer before that. And that’s just the past four years.”

  Willy returned, awkwardly zipping up his white suit while holding the hat, gloves, and booties, all with one hand. Everyone knew better than to offer to help. Sam took advantage of his approach to get outfitted herself.

  “Not to sound obvious,” Willy said, having overheard the conversation. “But if the guy’s too messed up to recognize, how do you know who he is?”

  “Wallet,” Ron explained shortly. “It was poking out of his front pants pocket. I could snag it without disturbing anything else. I had dispatch run his license through CAD, and there were enough common traits to make it look pretty likely he’s the guy, including a tattoo on his forearm.”

  Willy pursed his lips but withheld comment, pointing toward the apartment with his chin instead. “She find the body?” he asked.

  “Yeah, after a night of barhopping.”

  “She share the place with anyone?”

  Klesczewski shook his head. “Not that you can tell. I didn’t get into the nitty-gritty with her—didn’t want to trample too much ground ahead of you guys. But I got the feeling she wasn’t beyond getting help with the rent the old-fashioned way.”

  “She’s a hooker,” Willy restated bluntly, leaning against the rickety railing and pulling on the booties as Sam returned, typically all ready to go.

  “Amateur, I’d guess,” Ron suggested. “Officially, she works at the grocery store.”

  Willy nodded.

  Sam asked, “What do we have on Castine?”

  “He’s a kid diddler,” Willy said without looking up.

  They both stared at him, taken off guard.

  “You know this guy?” Sam asked.

  “I know about him,” Willy answered her, intent on his task. “We never busted him when we were with the PD, but he was a person-of-interest a dozen times or more—buying booze for kids, crawling around the edge of underage parties, offering rides after school. One of those scumbags you know is dirty, but you can’t catch him.”

  Sam glanced at Ron, who shrugged and said, “He’s right. I don’t have much to add. He lives in a one-room efficiency on Main Street—or lived, I should say. I have someone sitting on that. He worked as a part-time stacker and loader at one of the lumber companies. I got someone else getting a list of coworkers and buddies there, along with anything that might be interesting.” He added carefully, seeing Willy’s expression darken, “Nothing too intense. We’re not conducting interviews—just collecting data.”

  Willy laid one latex glove on the railing, wriggled inside of it with four fingers, and finished pulling it on with his teeth. “How screwed up is this scene, with all the pickpocketing and whatever?” he then asked.

  Ron was ready for that one. “Babbitt found the body, used the phone to call 911, and then waited right here. The responding officer—Rich Matthews, who deserves a high five as far as I’m concerned—grilled her first for a couple of minutes, and then literally tiptoed in to determine that Castine was really dead and alone. He didn’t touch anything; came out the same way he went in; and then sealed the place up. He even took his boots off before he went in.”

  Willy scowled. “That’s weird. He nuts? What if somebody had been hiding in the closet?”

  Ron tilted his head to one side. “I know, I know. A little over the top. But he’s fresh out of the academy and a little paranoid about scene preservation. I already talked to him. Anyhow, the scene’s pretty good.”

  “Except for you,” Willy commented.

  “True,” Ron admitted. “I suited up to confirm what R
ich had seen, mostly because he is new. And along with the wallet, I took some baseline shots. But that’s it.”

  “You call the ME?”

  “Him and the state’s attorney, but I also told them to hold tight until the crime lab arrived.”

  Sam reached out and patted her old colleague on the arm. “You did good, Ron. Like always. Thanks.”

  Willy didn’t say anything, but moved to the apartment’s door and glanced over his shoulder at his partner. “You ready?”

  It wasn’t much, Wayne Castine’s last resting place. A hallway with a bathroom on one side and the kitchen opposite, leading to a small living room and a bedroom beyond. There were a couple of closets, with nobody in them, and a smattering of mismatched furniture. It wasn’t terribly dirty, smelled mostly of cheap soap and makeup, and bragged of an awkward Middle Eastern motif, or maybe South American, consisting of gauzy scarves and odd pieces of fabric draped across the windows and over lamp shades.

  Sammie studied Willy as he preceded her slowly down the hall, keeping his feet on the strip of brown butcher paper that Ron had laid out on the floor. She could sense through his body language—as he paused here and there, his latex-clad fingers sometimes extending as in a failed effort to reach out—a desire to absorb what might have happened in this now dull, quiet, otherwise mundane little home.

  It was an understandable ambition, since what they could see, in the absence still of any dead body, spoke of grim and relentless violence. On the hallway’s floor, smearing the walls and doorjambs, splattered and dripped and swiped as in a child’s finger painting, was more blood than either one of them had witnessed in a long while.

  Whatever else was left behind from the events of the night just past, certainly the lingering ghost of pure rage loomed large.